What is the difference between workers compensation and short-term disability?
Workers compensation pays only when the injury or illness arose out of the job. Short-term disability pays when it did not. They cover opposite halves of the same risk, and an employee out of work is almost always claiming on one or the other, never both.
Tell us the situation.
A licensed human replies the same business day — not an auto-responder, and not five producers calling at once. We shop it across our carriers and tell you if the policy you already have is the right one.
We use this to quote and service your insurance, and we do not sell it or pass it to lead networks. Privacy policy.
The detail
Workers compensation responds only to injury or illness arising out of and in the course of employment. An off-the-job injury, a routine illness or a pregnancy is outside its scope entirely.
US Department of Labor, Office of Workers’ Compensation Programs
Workers compensation medical benefits pay treatment costs in full with no deductible or copay for a covered work injury. Short-term disability pays no medical costs at all — it replaces income only.
US Department of Labor, state workers’ compensation programme summaries
Five states and Puerto Rico require employers to provide short-term disability benefits: California, New York, New Jersey, Rhode Island and Hawaii. Everywhere else it is voluntary.
Social Security Administration, state temporary disability insurance programmes
Workers compensation wage replacement is generally set by state statute at around two-thirds of the average weekly wage, subject to a state maximum, and is normally not taxable.
US Department of Labor, state workers’ compensation programme summaries
What this means for you
- If you carry workers compensation and no disability cover — which describes most small employers — you have insured the smaller half. Most reasons a working-age person stops working are not work-related.
- The two do not stack. An employee cannot collect both for the same absence, and group disability policies exclude anything compensable under workers compensation.
- Who pays the disability premium determines whether the benefit is taxed. Employer-paid means the benefit is taxable when claimed; employee-paid with post-tax dollars means it is tax-free. For a 60% benefit that difference is the difference between coping and not.
- In California, New York, New Jersey, Rhode Island and Hawaii you already provide statutory short-term disability. The question there is only whether to top it up, because the statutory benefit is capped well below most salaries.
Related questions
- An employee hurt their back — but they are not sure where. Which one applies?
- It gets decided as a workers compensation question first, because that determines whether the disability policy is even in play. Report it to your workers compensation carrier and let them investigate rather than deciding in-house: a cumulative-trauma back injury in a manual role is frequently found compensable even when no single incident can be pointed to. If the claim is denied as non-work-related, the short-term disability policy then responds. Employers who quietly route a doubtful claim to disability to protect their comp experience are creating a much larger problem than the one they are avoiding.
- We have a small team. Is disability cover worth the money?
- The premium is typically $15 to $40 per employee per month for short-term cover replacing around 60% of pay, which puts it well below dental as a share of the benefits budget, and it is commonly offered on a voluntary employee-paid basis at no employer cost at all. The case for it is not really financial — it is that when a key employee is out for three months with something that has nothing to do with work, the alternatives are paying them anyway out of cash flow, or not, and neither is a good position for a small business to discover it is in.
- Does FMLA cover the wages?
- No, and this is the most common misunderstanding of the three. FMLA gives eligible employees up to 12 weeks of job-protected unpaid leave at employers with 50 or more employees — it protects the job, not the income. Short-term disability is what pays during that leave. Several states now run their own paid family and medical leave programmes that do pay, with rules quite different from the federal FMLA, so check the state before assuming the federal answer.
Need this handled?
We do the filings, and we place the accounts other brokers decline — lapsed authority, claims history, new ventures. Tell us the situation and a licensed human replies the same business day.